Coal is Dirty…Any way you scrub it

October 13, 2009

Cleansing the Air at the Expense of Waterways
By CHARLES DUHIGG

MASONTOWN, Pa. — For years, residents here complained about the yellow smoke pouring from the tall chimneys of the nearby coal-fired power plant, which left a film on their cars and pebbles of coal waste in their yards. Five states — including New York and New Jersey — sued the plant’s owner, Allegheny Energy, claiming the air pollution was causing respiratory diseases and acid rain.

So three years ago, when Allegheny Energy decided to install scrubbers to clean the plant’s air emissions, environmentalists were overjoyed. The technology would spray water and chemicals through the plant’s chimneys, trapping more than 150,000 tons of pollutants each year before they escaped into the sky.

But the cleaner air has come at a cost. Each day since the equipment was switched on in June, the company has dumped tens of thousands of gallons of wastewater containing chemicals from the scrubbing process into the Monongahela River, which provides drinking water to 350,000 people and flows into Pittsburgh, 40 miles to the north.

“It’s like they decided to spare us having to breathe in these poisons, but now we have to drink them instead,” said Philip Coleman, who lives about 15 miles from the plant and has asked a state judge to toughen the facility’s pollution regulations. “We can’t escape.”

Even as a growing number of coal-burning power plants around the nation have moved to reduce their air emissions, many of them are creating another problem: water pollution. Power plants are the nation’s biggest producer of toxic waste, surpassing industries like plastic and paint manufacturing and chemical plants, according to a New York Times analysis of Environmental Protection Agency data.

Much power plant waste once went into the sky, but because of toughened air pollution laws, it now often goes into lakes and rivers, or into landfills that have leaked into nearby groundwater, say regulators and environmentalists.

Officials at the plant here in southwest Pennsylvania — named Hatfield’s Ferry — say it does not pose any health or environmental risks because they have installed equipment to limit the toxins the facility releases into the Monongahela River and elsewhere.

But as the number of scrubbers around the nation increases, environmentalists — including those in Pennsylvania — have become worried. The Environmental Protection Agency projects that by next year, roughly 50 percent of coal-generated electricity in the United States will come from plants that use scrubbers or similar technologies, creating vast new sources of wastewater.

Yet no federal regulations specifically govern the disposal of power plant discharges into waterways or landfills. Some regulators have used laws like the Clean Water Act to combat such pollution. But those laws can prove inadequate, say regulators, because they do not mandate limits on the most dangerous chemicals in power plant waste, like arsenic and lead.

For instance, only one in 43 power plants and other electric utilities across the nation must limit how much barium they dump into nearby waterways, according to a Times analysis of E.P.A. records. Barium, which is commonly found in power plant waste and scrubber wastewater, has been linked to heart problems and diseases in other organs.

Even when power plant emissions are regulated by the Clean Water Act, plants have often violated that law without paying fines or facing other penalties. Ninety percent of 313 coal-fired power plants that have violated the Clean Water Act since 2004 were not fined or otherwise sanctioned by federal or state regulators, according to a Times analysis of Environmental Protection Agency records. (An interactive database of power plant violations around the nation is available at www.nytimes.com/coalplants.)

Fines for Plants Modest

Other plants have paid only modest fines. For instance, Hatfield’s Ferry has violated the Clean Water Act 33 times since 2006. For those violations, the company paid less than $26,000. During that same period, the plant’s parent company earned $1.1 billion.

“We know that coal waste is so dangerous that we don’t want it in the air, and that’s why we’ve told power plants they have to install scrubbers,” said Senator Barbara Boxer, the California Democrat who is chairwoman of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works. “So why are they dumping the same waste into people’s water?”

Though the Environmental Protection Agency promised earlier this decade to consider new regulations on power plant waste — and reiterated that pledge after a Tennessee dam break sent 1.1 billion gallons of coal waste into farms and homes last year — federal regulators have yet to issue any major new rules.

One reason is that some state governments have long fought new federal regulations, often at the behest of energy executives, say environmentalists and regulators.

The counties surrounding Hatfield’s Ferry, which are home to multiple universities, are an example of what hangs in the balance as this debate plays out.

Last year, when Hatfield’s Ferry asked the state for permission to dump scrubber wastewater into the Monongahela River, the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection approved the request with proposed limits on some chemicals.

But state officials placed no limits on water discharges of arsenic, aluminum, boron, chromium, manganese, nickel or other chemicals that have been linked to health risks, all of which have been detected in the plant’s wastewater samples, according to state documents.

Records show, and company officials concede, that Hatfield’s Ferry is already dumping scrubber wastewater into the Monongahela that violates the state’s few proposed pollution rules. Moreover, those rules have been suspended until a judge decides on the plant’s appeal of the proposed limits.

“You can get used to the plant, and the noise and soot on your cars,” said Father Rodney Torbic, the priest at the St. George Serbian Orthodox Church, across the road from Hatfield’s Ferry. “But I see people suffering every day because of this pollution.”

Officials at Hatfield’s Ferry say there is no reason for residents to be concerned. They say that lawsuits against the plant are without merit, and that they have installed a $25 million water treatment plant that removes many of the toxic particles and solids from scrubber wastewater. The solids are put into a 106-acre landfill that contains a synthetic liner to prevent leaks.

Officials say that the plant’s pollution does not pose any risk. Limits on arsenic, aluminum, barium, boron, cadmium, chromium, manganese and nickel are not appropriate, the company wrote in a statement, because the plant’s wastewater is not likely to cause the Monongahela River to exceed safety levels for those contaminants.

“Allegheny has installed state-of-the-art scrubbers, state-of-the-art wastewater treatment, and state-of-the-art synthetic liners,” the company wrote in a statement. “We operate to be in compliance with all environmental laws and will continue to do so.”

The plant’s water treatment facility, however, does not remove all dissolved metals and chemicals, many of which go into the river, executives concede. An analysis of records from other plants with scrubbers indicates that such wastewater often contains high concentrations of dissolved arsenic, barium, boron, iron, manganese, cadmium, magnesium and other heavy metals that have been shown to contribute to cancer, organ failures and other diseases. Company officials say the emissions by the plant will not pose health risks, because they will be diluted in the river.

Though synthetic liners are generally considered effective at preventing leaks, environmentalists note that the Hatfield’s Ferry landfill is less than a mile uphill from the river, and that over time, other types of liners have proven less reliable than initially hoped.

The Environmental Protection Agency, in a statement last month, said it planned to revise standards for water discharges from coal-fired power plants like Hatfield’s Ferry. Agency studies have concluded that “current regulations, which were issued in 1982, have not kept pace with changes that have occurred in the electric power industry,” officials wrote.

But some environmentalists and lawmakers say that such rules will not be enough, and that new laws are needed that force plants to use more expensive technologies that essentially eliminate toxic discharges.

Cleaning Up Pollution

“It’s really important to set a precedent that tells power plants that they need to genuinely clean up pollution, rather than just shift it from the air to the water,” said Abigail Dillen, a lawyer with the law firm Earthjustice, which represents two advocacy organizations, the Environmental Integrity Project and the Citizens Coal Council, in asking a Pennsylvania court to toughen regulations on Hatfield’s Ferry.

Ms. Dillen, like other environmentalists, has urged courts and lawmakers to force plants to adopt “zero discharge” treatment facilities, which are more expensive but can eliminate most pollution.

State officials say they have established appropriate water pollution limits for Hatfield’s Ferry, and have strict standards for landfill disposal.

“We asked the plant for estimates on how much of various pollutants they are likely to emit, and based on those estimates, we set limits that are protective of the Monongahela,” said Ron Schwartz, a state environmental official. “We have asked them to monitor some chemicals, including arsenic, and if levels grow too high, we may intervene.”

However, environmental groups have argued in court documents and interviews that Hatfield’s Ferry probably will emit dangerous chemicals, and that they fear the state is unlikely to intervene.

Similar problems have emerged elsewhere. Twenty-one power plants in 10 states, including Alabama, Kentucky, North Carolina and Ohio, have dumped arsenic into rivers or other waters at concentrations as much as 18 times the federal drinking water standard, according to a Times analysis of E.P.A. data.

In Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, North Carolina, Ohio, Wisconsin and elsewhere, power plants have dumped other chemicals at dangerous concentrations. Few of those plants have ever been sanctioned for those emissions, nor were their discharge permits altered to prevent future pollution.

Records indicate that power plant landfills and other disposal practices have polluted groundwater in more than a dozen states, contaminating the water in some towns with toxic chemicals. A 2007 report published by the E.P.A. suggested that people living near some power plant landfills faced a cancer risk 2,000 times higher than federal health standards.

Lobbyists Block Controls

In 2000, Environmental Protection Agency officials tried to issue stricter controls on power plant waste. But a lobbying campaign by the coal and power industries, as well as public officials in 13 states, blocked the effort. In 2008 alone, according to campaign finance reports, power companies donated $20 million to the political campaigns of federal lawmakers, almost evenly divided between Democrats and Republicans.

In interviews, E.P.A. officials said that toughening pollution rules for power plants was among their top priorities. Last month, the agency announced it was moving forward on new rules regulating greenhouse gas emissions from hundreds of power plants and other large industrial facilities. Lisa P. Jackson, who was confirmed to head the agency in January, has said she would determine by the end of the year whether certain power plant byproducts should be treated as hazardous waste, which would subject them to tougher regulations.

But for now, there are no new rules on power plant waste. And many states are trying to dissuade Ms. Jackson from creating new regulations, according to state and federal regulators, because they worry that new rules will burden overworked regulators, and because power plants have pressured local politicians to fight greater regulation.

For instance, Pennsylvania has opposed designating the waste from Hatfield’s Ferry and other power plants as hazardous. In a statement, the Department of Environmental Protection said the state had “sufficient state and federal laws and regulations at our disposal to control wastewater discharges at levels protective of the environment and public health.”

But residents living near power plants disagree.

“Americans want cheap electricity, but those of us who live around power plants are the ones who have to pay for it,” Mr. Coleman said. “It’s like being in the third world.”

Karl Russell contributed reporting.water_600

Share and Enjoy:
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook
  • email
  • LinkedIn
  • Print
  • Reddit
  • TwitThis
  • Yahoo! Buzz

185 Responses to “Coal is Dirty…Any way you scrub it”

  1. KCSrailroad Says:

    OK, so we shut down the coal mines, all of them. How many people are put out of work? It will put a severe hurt on the railroads who ship out the coal all over the midwest and east coast. How many people will lose jobs there? Oh, and what fuels will power plants in the midwest and east coast use to create electricity? Remember, they have to charge up those batter-powered cars, you know… Oil? Oil is bad as well. Nuclear? Hydrogen? It too will blow up. So what energy source do you propose? None? How about turning back the clock of time to the 19th century when the U.S. what an agrarian society and a 2nd rate power. Is that what you want? Let’s be honest here. And, by the way, what kind of car do you drive and how many electrical appliances do you have around the house? Don’t forget your flat scree tv’s… Hypoctrits all!

  2. KCSrailroad Says:

    By the way, does this website reach China? Have you been there. They burn “brown” coal, you know. Do you think that a Communist government really cares what you have to say? I think not so go back from under the rock you came out of.

  3. indrawati Says:

    indrawati…

    “[...]Coal is Dirty…Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org[...]“…

  4. if he pays up these links will be taken off Says:

    if he pays up these links will be taken off…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  5. UGLY BITCH Says:

    UGLY BITCH…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  6. if he pays up these links will be taken off Says:

    if he pays up these links will be taken off…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  7. if he pays up these links will be taken off Says:

    if he pays up these links will be taken off…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  8. china Says:

    china…

    Such go perfectly through fitted a pair of jeans and / or nylons nestled in china. Just a lovely lady 50 will show up great—my foot orthotics quite possibly meet interior that makes china tremendously nice make up for the actual losing mid-foot servi…

  9. he scammed innocent writers for your site SEO Says:

    he scammed innocent writers for your site SEO…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  10. he scammed innocent writers for your site SEO Says:

    he scammed innocent writers for your site SEO…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  11. if he pays up these links will be taken off Says:

    if he pays up these links will be taken off…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  12. click through the next web site Says:

    click through the next web site…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  13. portefeuille lancel Says:

    portefeuille lancel…

    Last month, Dr. His training methods are the seed of every dog trainer across the globe. His website Dog Star Daily is a tremendous resource full of articles; audio, video and free downloads….

  14. Michael Kors Purses Says:

    Michael Kors Purses…

    Our son offered me that of moms day. He knows im not concerning price tag and yet exactly what comes from their center. I can’t believe it has our preferred shade and/or truly meets the wrist. I did not might find bracelets to suit headphonesmy little…

  15. Lululemon pants Says:

    Lululemon pants…

    Bought that as being a present of my personal mom additionally she loved this. sweet top quality amazing price tag as well as our mother liked information technology. Furthermore sent very fast. When you need a gift quickly while like this then this is…

  16. Cartier Love Bracelet UK Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet UK…

    Your supplement ended up being with that very good cost I never believe all grade would be so that excellent. Its breathtaking. This one mama is going to adore it at Xmas morning whenever she opens gift and it appears as though I spent far more, and ye…

  17. replica gucci bags outlet online Says:

    replica gucci bags outlet online…

    Thank You! Love It!…

  18. Cheap Nike Air Max 90 Says:

    Cheap Nike Air Max 90…

    I ordered your searching for a very good gifts towards our mother. Your headphone arrived in a striking purple tied box. This was ideal searching present below their christmas time tree!! The actual headphone even looked gorgeous, however my personal m…

  19. Cartier Love Bracelet Replica Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet Replica…

    I have our gifts to our mom for Christmas because she is the best jewelry freak. On one thing she does not use far out of is, bracelets. I purchased the lady it appeal bracelet to whenever she started information technology yesterday she absolutley enj…

  20. Coach Factory Outlet Online Says:

    Coach Factory Outlet Online…

    I obtained it looking for a very good gifts of my personal mama. That the headphone arrived in a stunning purple tied container. This was the greatest hunting gifts underneath all christmas tree!! The headphone and seemed beautiful, although the mama a…

  21. Cartier Love Bracelet Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet…

    I ordered that for the my personal mom not really anticipating a great deal since things ended up being quite cheap. Once I got it I was thrilled! It is beautiful & does not appear inexpensive at all! My personal mother loved that it!…

  22. Cartier love bracelet price Says:

    Cartier love bracelet price…

    Really mother’s evening gifts. Conversely, their bracelet got besides extended to come, and it came following the vacation. My mom indicated that she loved their bracelet, although We have not really viewed the lady put on that it though. :-)…

  23. Cartier Love ring Says:

    Cartier Love ring…

    it comes down in a pretty box looks awesome then again their a bit mini additionally to my parents wrist however it looks awesome only wish they ended up being much longer…

  24. Cartier Love Bracelet Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet…

    I paid for this trying to find a ideal gift towards the mama. The headphone came within a pretty purple tied up container. This was ideal lookin present less than on christmas time tree!! Your headphone and looked striking, conversely the mama was giga…

  25. Cartier Juste Un Clou Says:

    Cartier Juste Un Clou…

    I have the present for the mom for the Xmas simply because she is letter jewelry freak. The actual something she cannot don much to are, bracelets. I bought her your charm bracelet plus anytime she launched that it yesterday she absolutley enjoyed it! …

  26. Nike Roshe Run Says:

    Nike Roshe Run…

    Goods appeared before then organized, very fast! It offers a good texture and also extremely brilliant hues. Most pleased using this buying so in-pricey !:)prefer things!…

  27. Cheap Nike air force 1 Says:

    Cheap Nike air force 1…

    Ideal mother’s day present. However, some sort of bracelet got too prolonged towards appear, and it came after the vacation. My mom indicated that will she loved that the bracelet, yet I have maybe not seen this girl use that it still. :-)…

  28. Coach Factory Outlet Online Says:

    Coach Factory Outlet Online…

    I acquired your looking for a awesome gift to my personal mama. That the headphone arrived in a stunning purple tied package. This is ideal searching present below that christmas tree!! Some sort of headphone in addition seemed awesome, although our ma…

  29. Coach Outlet Online Says:

    Coach Outlet Online…

    Great headphonespick, nicely priced additionally exactly what is actually displayed. Pretty gifts box plus poem additionally enclosed. Awesome of mother’s time!…

  30. Moncler Outlet online Says:

    Moncler Outlet online…

    sThe premium it awesome, nevertheless, due that models operated slight accept that it an shape upward.If you are 5f 4inches therefore length specifications modifying or only put on truly high shoes or boots. Besides that loved some sort of dress…

  31. Mulberry UK Says:

    Mulberry UK…

    http://overseasoverwhelmed.com/about.php?p=mbt-prezzi-scarpembt outlet…

  32. Cartier Love Bracelet Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet…

    Purchased this as being a gifts for our mama and/or she liked they. good top quality good amount and my mother liked this. Also sent super fast. So if you require a present accelerated while such as this compared to this is basically the an one should …

  33. http://www.airporttransmission.com/tokyoshoes/NewBalance/ibrpM4QYjb.html Says:

    http://www.airporttransmission.com/tokyoshoes/NewBalance/ibrpM4QYjb.html

    ¡îºúÂ餢¤ó¥Ñ¥ó…

  34. Cheap Beats studio Says:

    Cheap Beats studio…

    I bought all bracelets for the limited grandchilren on promote at thier mothers.Their babes mothers absolutely adored consumers and I is most impressed among consumers for the rate I paid….

  35. beats by dr dre Says:

    beats by dr dre…

    Yet not just as fancy inside real world provided mothers wrist was maybe not 2small dont pick things cause they become tight .. their sweet and yet things yur 5year existing can make . Non your reduced their an ok gifts at bring but not the best wow gi…

  36. http://Cartier Love Bracelet Says:

    http://Cartier Love Bracelet…

    I got this one being a gifts concerning our sibling, pleased mother. She adored they!! I was scared it was going to be also slight because of the past evaluations as well as how this looked when I got per peak, but it in shape extremely well. Things ap…

  37. kahancock.com Says:

    kahancock.com…

    A designated Designer Rack takes the guesswork out of searching for higher end pieces. In addition, you find luxury shoes, bags, and other accessories displayed behind the checkout counter. For your consideration, may I present Christian Louboutin deep…

  38. Coach Wallets Says:

    Coach Wallets…

    This system is with that great amount I by no means thought on good is hence excellent. Its perfect. It mom will enjoy this regarding Holiday early morning anytime she starts gifts and it seems like I spent a great deal more, and yet pricing was really…

  39. http://www.chsboosters.org/tokyonewshoes/VANS/D4nIkGQf0t.html Says:

    http://www.chsboosters.org/tokyonewshoes/VANS/D4nIkGQf0t.html

    Ò»ÈËÂäDZ¾µ±¤Ï¥ï¥¯¥ï¥¯¤·¤¿¤¤¤±¤É¡¢ØŸÈÎÖØ´ó¤Ç¡¢¤Ê¤ó¤À¤«²»°²¤Ç¤¹ÒýÔ½¤·Îݤµ¤ó¤Ë¤âÔÂÄ©¤Ï¤â¤¦¤¤¤Ã¤Ñ¤¤¤ÇŸoÀí¤Ç¤¹¤Ê¤ó¤ÆÑÔ¤ï¤ì¤Æ¡¢±¾µ±¤Ë¥Ð¥¿¥Ð¥¿¤·¤½¤¦brassy¤µ¤ó¡¢ÊýÉ٤ʤ¤Îï¼þ¤ÎÖФǤªšÝ¤Ë¤¤¤ê¤¬¤¢¤ë¤È¤¤¤¤¤Ç¤¹¤Í¤Á¤Ê¤ß¤Ë¡¢¬FÔÚ˽¤¬×¡¤ó¤Ç¤¤¤ë¥Þ¥ó¥·¥ç¥ó¡¢½Y˜‹È˚ݤ¢¤ê…

  40. Michael Kors outlet online Says:

    Michael Kors outlet online…

    I ordered this trying to find a awesome present to my mama. Their headphone emerged within a pretty purple tied container. This was ideal hunting gifts below that the christmas tree!! Your headphone additionally seemed beautiful, then again my personal…

  41. http://garden-gate.net/tokyojewelry/KONRON/bdYka54mcj.html Says:

    http://garden-gate.net/tokyojewelry/KONRON/bdYka54mcj.html

    È¥ÄêF1¤òÓQ¤ËÐФ¯•r¤Ëʹ¤Ã¤¿¤À¤±¤Ç¡¢¥­¥ì¥¤¤Ç¤¹¡£¸÷$3.00 ¥Û¥Ã¥È¥±©`¥­ÐÍ…

  42. Cheap Beats by dre Says:

    Cheap Beats by dre…

    I obtained this one trying to find a awesome gift towards the mom. Ones headphone emerged in a pretty purple tied up container. This was ideal hunting gift under ones holiday tree!! Ones headphone additionally seemed perfect, however my mama was larger…

  43. Cartier Love Bracelet Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet…

    But not like fancy in real life when mothers wrist are never 2small dont go for that influence it be tight .. it really is sweet then again whatever yur 5year older make . No the actual reduced their one okay gift to award but not a wow present…cant …

  44. Coach Factory Outlet Says:

    Coach Factory Outlet…

    I had gotten it headphonesconcerning my personal mom to mothers evening, and/or she definitely enjoyed things! It is completely cute headphonesas well as the stating on the card it will come in the package is very sentimental!! And the top quality of t…

  45. http://embroidery.smvinc.com/tokyojpgoods/BodyCare/prq0xvpFMz.html Says:

    http://embroidery.smvinc.com/tokyojpgoods/BodyCare/prq0xvpFMz.html

    ¤³¤Á¤é¤âÈÕ±¾¤Ë¤¢¤ë¥·¥ç¥Ã¥×¡£¥Ç¥£¥º¥Ë©`¥¹¥È¥¢¤ÎÓ¢ÕZ°æ¥µ¥¤¥È¡£¥Ç¥£¥º¥Ë©`¤Î¥­¥ã¥é¥¯¥¿©`ÉÌÆ·¤ä¥Ç¥£¥º¥Ë©`Ó³»­¤Î¥­¥ã¥é¥¯¥¿©`¥°¥Ã¥º¤Ê¤É¡¢¤Þ¤À¡¢ÈÕ±¾¤Ç¤Ï°k‰Ó¤µ¤ì¤Æ¤¤¤Ê¤¤¤â¤ÎُÈ뤹¤ë¤³¤È¤¬¿ÉÄܤǤ¹¡£…

  46. Cartier Love Bracelet Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet…

    Purchased the being a gifts to my mama to she enjoyed information technology. wonderful premium amazing expense furthermore my mother enjoyed that it. Also sent ultra fast. So if you need a gift fast while such as this then this is actually the a singl…

  47. seo Says:

    seo…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  48. scoresod Says:

    scoresod…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  49. www.grss-ieee.org/louis-vuitton/ Says:

    http://www.grss-ieee.org/louis-vuitton/...

    “I didn’t think he was serious,” Kraushaar said. “I told him the idea was absurd and out of the question.”…

  50. Cheap Beats solo Says:

    Cheap Beats solo…

    Yet not because fancy inside real life if you think moms wrist is actually maybe not 2small don’t go for that it cause things stay tight .. it really is sweet and yet something yur 5year aged can make . Non the not so the a ok gifts at offer yet not p…

  51. lululemon pants Says:

    lululemon pants…

    I bought some bracelets for the my little grandchilren and render on thier moms.All ladies parents definitely liked these people and I also ended up being really impressed using consumers for cost I compensated….

  52. http://family.coreen.biz/tokyocarshop/Monkey4MINI/BM5uoWKbj6.html Says:

    http://family.coreen.biz/tokyocarshop/Monkey4MINI/BM5uoWKbj6.html

    ¥¤¥ë¥Á¥§¥»©`¥ë¤Ï…âÎĤ¬³É¹¦¤·¤¿¤³¤È¤òÖª¤ê¡¢šZϲ¤Î±íÇé¤ò¸¡¤«¤Ù¤Æïw¤ÓÌø¤Í¤¿¡¸¤ä¤Ã¤¿¤ï£¡´ó³É¹¦£¡¤¸¤ã¤¢¡¢¤³¤Ã¤Á¤ËÐФ±¤Ð¡¢¸¸˜”¤Èĸ˜”¤¬³ö»á¤Ã¤¿¥»¥ë¥àºþ¤Ê¤Î¤Í£¡¡¹…

  53. taengball Says:

    taengball…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  54. ibesttravel.com Says:

    ibesttravel.com…

    “[...]Coal is Dirty…Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org[...]“…

  55. Nike Air Max+ 2012 Says:

    Nike Air Max+ 2012…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  56. www.soydebarrio.do/?pid=311 Says:

    http://www.soydebarrio.do/?pid=311...

    Mulberry is a powerful and incredibly versatile email client available for all the popular platforms. If there is something Mulberry lacks, it is simplicity….

  57. Nike Roshe Run Women Says:

    Nike Roshe Run Women…

    Our son provided me personally that for moms day. He understands im not up to price tag then again just what originates from their heart. I can’t feel it has the preferred color additionally actually suits my personal wrist. I do not might uncover bra…

  58. read the article Says:

    read the article…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  59. ballteng Says:

    ballteng…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  60. ????????????????????? Says:

    ?????????????????????…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  61. accessories cat Says:

    accessories cat…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  62. Hermes H bracelet Says:

    Hermes H bracelet…

    Right mother’s day present. Nevertheless, their bracelet got too lengthy at arrive, therefore appeared after the getaway. The mother conveyed that will she loved that bracelet, even though I have not really viewed this girl use it yet. :-)…

  63. http://www.ustaogluotomotiv.com/tokyocarshop/MotorcycleParts/yf2FYWufsh.html Says:

    http://www.ustaogluotomotiv.com/tokyocarshop/MotorcycleParts/yf2FYWufsh.html

    ¥«¥ì©`¥Ñ¥ó¤Ã¤ÆÖФËÈë¤Ã¤È¤ë¥«¥ì©`¤¬¤ª¤¤¤·¤¯¤Ê¤¤¤È¤µ¤¨¤ó¤â¤ó¤Í…

  64. crates crate Says:

    crates crate…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  65. Cartier Love Bracelet Says:

    Cartier Love Bracelet…

    But not while fancy at real life if you think moms wrist is maybe not 2small don’t pick it influence that become tight .. their cute but something yur 5year old can make . No your not so its a great okay present in order to offer yet not per wow prese…

  66. karen millen black dress Says:

    karen millen black dress…

    Everyone ought to individual male karen millen black dress :) All of the common are fantastic! They come rear yearly, so they really will likely not go out of form designed for years! Several could point out that shiny things cost excessively, though t…

  67. Cheap dr dre headphones Says:

    Cheap dr dre headphones…

    I had gotten this particular headphonesfor the our mother towards moms time, and/or she definitely enjoyed that it! It really is actually pretty headphonesand stating regarding the card that will comes in container is very sentimental!! As well as the …

  68. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  69. united credit consultants Says:

    united credit consultants…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  70. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  71. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  72. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  73. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  74. http://www.arleta-triangle.org/golf5/Bridgestone/xZ9EC0xjmL.html Says:

    http://www.arleta-triangle.org/golf5/Bridgestone/xZ9EC0xjmL.html

    ??????????2013?????55???????800??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????(Stradivarius??)…

  75. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  76. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  77. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  78. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  79. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  80. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  81. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  82. united credit consultants Says:

    united credit consultants…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  83. cat sweaters Says:

    cat sweaters…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  84. beachbody derm exclusive reviews Says:

    beachbody derm exclusive reviews…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  85. parfum hollister Says:

    parfum hollister…

    Ramada Plaza Fort Walton Beach Resort/Destin…

  86. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  87. united credit consultants Says:

    united credit consultants…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  88. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  89. hollister kids Says:

    hollister kids…

    Mr. Taylor, age 26, was in. a car accident a week ago and Suffered several third degree burns on His arms and upper body. He is ble to stand without assistance….

  90. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  91. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  92. United Credit Consultants Says:

    United Credit Consultants…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  93. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  94. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  95. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  96. ??????? Says:

    ???????…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  97. ??????? Says:

    ???????…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  98. karen millen dresses online outlet Says:

    karen millen dresses online outlet…

    http://galleri-gl-lejre.dk/karen-millen.asp?karen-millen-one-shoulder-c-13.html

  99. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  100. http://beavssoftball-com.bobafett.parcomweb.net/golf2/Dunlop/sB6X5a8gzu.html Says:

    http://beavssoftball-com.bobafett.parcomweb.net/golf2/Dunlop/sB6X5a8gzu.html

    ???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????…

  101. discount nike air max Says:

    discount nike air max…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  102. united credit consultants Says:

    united credit consultants…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  103. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  104. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  105. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  106. Telefonkatalogen.biz Says:

    Telefonkatalogen.biz…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  107. derm exclusive review Says:

    derm exclusive review…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  108. online reputation management real estate Says:

    online reputation management real estate…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  109. http://move.lilieonline.com/Tires8/NITTO/vGK3MmQT0J.html Says:

    http://move.lilieonline.com/Tires8/NITTO/vGK3MmQT0J.html

    ¡ºîB¹Ì¤Ê›A¤ì¤â¥¹¥Ã¥­¥ê£¡¥Þ¥¸¥«¥ë¥Ñ¥ï©`¥·©`¥È¥¨¥Í¥ê©`¥óö¡»…

  110. cheap air max 1 liberty Says:

    cheap air max 1 liberty…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  111. replica nike air max Says:

    replica nike air max…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  112. loans for bad credit Says:

    loans for bad credit…

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org…

  113. ebay karen millen dresses Says:

    ebay karen millen dresses…

    http://vendelbo-vans.dk/karen-millen.asp?karen-millen-dm153-signature-stretch-satin-dress-aubergine-2013-sale-p-375.html

  114. http://www.jnk.johnfishersr.net/golf1/Bridgestone/f03tpNFwmH.html Says:

    http://www.jnk.johnfishersr.net/golf1/Bridgestone/f03tpNFwmH.html

    ?1???????????????????…

  115. silversuitesresidences.com/?id=596 Says:

    silversuitesresidences.com/?id=596…

    The new tanks being followed by a less costly upgrade of LAV III and TAPV in conjunction with a new capability on the battlefield would be a game changer….

  116. Nike Air Max Cheap Says:

    Nike Air Max Cheap

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  117. discount air max Says:

    discount air max

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  118. publicist online reputation management Says:

    publicist online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  119. union reputation management Says:

    union reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  120. publicist online reputation management Says:

    publicist online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  121. online reputation management for mortgage brokers Says:

    online reputation management for mortgage brokers

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  122. online reputation management for mortgage brokers Says:

    online reputation management for mortgage brokers

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  123. union reputation management Says:

    union reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  124. union reputation management Says:

    union reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  125. publicist online reputation management Says:

    publicist online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  126. bailiff online reputation management Says:

    bailiff online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  127. online reputation management for mortgage brokers Says:

    online reputation management for mortgage brokers

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  128. tax collector online reputation management Says:

    tax collector online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  129. union reputation management Says:

    union reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  130. Dr. Vincent Malfitano Says:

    Dr. Vincent Malfitano

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  131. Dr. Vincent Malfitano Says:

    Dr. Vincent Malfitano

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  132. bailiff online reputation management Says:

    bailiff online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  133. publicist online reputation management Says:

    publicist online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  134. online reputation management for mortgage brokers Says:

    online reputation management for mortgage brokers

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  135. union reputation management Says:

    union reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  136. union reputation management Says:

    union reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  137. tax collector online reputation management Says:

    tax collector online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  138. publicist online reputation management Says:

    publicist online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  139. bailiff online reputation management Says:

    bailiff online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  140. tax collector online reputation management Says:

    tax collector online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  141. online reputation management for mortgage brokers Says:

    online reputation management for mortgage brokers

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  142. tax collector online reputation management Says:

    tax collector online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  143. bailiff online reputation management Says:

    bailiff online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  144. union reputation management Says:

    union reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  145. bailiff online reputation management Says:

    bailiff online reputation management

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  146. cheat dragon city gems Says:

    cheat dragon city gems

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  147. Best Acne Treatment products Says:

    Best Acne Treatment products

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  148. enjoyed this one Says:

    enjoyed this one

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  149. linked internet page Says:

    linked internet page

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  150. http://www.exhibitionsinternational.org/osakaTires/DELINTE/jFXq3amnCK.html Says:

    http://www.exhibitionsinternational.org/osakaTires/DELINTE/jFXq3amnCK.html

    ??????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????3?????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????????…

  151. Find out more about the UK on Wikipedia Says:

    Find out more about the UK on Wikipedia

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  152. monteklearningsolutions.com Says:

    monteklearningsolutions.com

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  153. cheap nike free run 2 Says:

    cheap nike free run 2

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  154. http://hihume.ru/Vigrx_Plus_Review_-_Is_Vigrx_Your_Best_Penile_enlargement_Option Says:

    http://hihume.ru/Vigrx_Plus_Review_-_Is_Vigrx_Your_Best_Penile_enlargement_Option

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  155. dragon city hack download Says:

    dragon city hack download

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  156. cheat dragon city Says:

    cheat dragon city

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  157. dragon city gem hack Says:

    dragon city gem hack

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  158. dragon city cheat Says:

    dragon city cheat

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  159. dragon city hack Says:

    dragon city hack

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  160. dragon city hack download Says:

    dragon city hack download

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  161. Chinese page on Wikipedia Says:

    Chinese page on Wikipedia

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  162. horizonweekly.com Says:

    horizonweekly.com

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  163. Air Jordan Femme New School Noir Blanc Says:

    Air Jordan Femme New School Noir Blanc

    Il n’y a pas de diamants dans le ciel, de sorte que vous n’êtes pas beau comme eux.

  164. http://www.sbwire.com/press-Releases/best-Acne-treatment-compelling-information-released-487218.htm Says:

    http://www.sbwire.com/press-Releases/best-Acne-treatment-compelling-information-released-487218.htm

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  165. girls bikini Says:

    girls bikini

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  166. derm exclusive night cream Says:

    derm exclusive night cream

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  167. Cheap Sport Blue 6s Says:

    Cheap Sport Blue 6s

    http://sportblue6sforsale.makesit.net/ zevxajcsyb Pre Order Sport Blue 6s jhtebxqquv

  168. dragon city hack Says:

    dragon city hack

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  169. http://www.mondoinweb.it/okjewelry/CHANLUU/OESekGeLUW.html Says:

    http://www.mondoinweb.it/okjewelry/CHANLUU/OESekGeLUW.html

    ??????????????????????????????????????????

  170. use this link Says:

    use this link

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  171. sources tell me Says:

    sources tell me

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  172. Vigrx Review Says:

    Vigrx Review

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  173. famanet.br Says:

    famanet.br

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  174. please click the following website Says:

    please click the following website

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  175. learn the facts here now Says:

    learn the facts here now

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  176. website designing company delhi, Says:

    website designing company delhi,

    [...]Coal is Dirty…Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org[...]

  177. best male enhancement products Says:

    best male enhancement products

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  178. dragon city cheats Says:

    dragon city cheats

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  179. jordan pas cher immobilier maroc Says:

    jordan pas cher immobilier maroc

    Kiehl’s was not in financial trouble. But Jami and her husband made the unusual decision to scale back. There were the usual suitors lots of them but Jami wanted to preserve the essence of the business and pass it on to her daughter. She soon learned…

  180. http://www.ristrutturarecasaroma.it/okjpbags/PORTER/Z6OWTknyda.html Says:

    http://www.ristrutturarecasaroma.it/okjpbags/PORTER/Z6OWTknyda.html

    ????????????????????????????????????????

  181. dragon city cheats Says:

    dragon city cheats

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  182. article source Says:

    article source

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  183. Vigrx Plus Ingredients Says:

    Vigrx Plus Ingredients

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  184. Vigrxplus Says:

    Vigrxplus

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

  185. google advertising rates Says:

    google advertising rates

    Coal is Dirty?Any way you scrub it | centerforenergymatters.org

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.